| Round |
Opponent |
Result |
| Overall Postseason Record: 33-22 (25 appearances) - through 2023 season |
| NATIONAL CHAMPIONS (3): 1973, 1983, 2022 |
| NATIONAL RUNNERS-UP (5): 1972, 1979, 1984, 2020, 2023 |
| NATIONAL SEMIFINALS (5): 1982, 1985, 1994, 2000, 2021 |
| NATIONAL QUARTERFINALS (6): 1978, 1988, 1996, 2003, 2006, 2017 |
| 2023 (Postseason Record: 3-1) |
| Second Round |
#14 Dordt |
W, 7-0 |
| Quarterfinals |
#10 Saint Xavier (Ill.) |
W, 34-17 |
| Semifinals |
#4 Georgetown (Ky.) |
W, 35-10 |
| Championship |
#3 Keiser (Fla.) |
L, 31-21 |
| 2022 (Postseason Record: 4-0) |
| First Round |
#17 Dickinson State (N.D.) |
W, 49-7 |
| Quarterfinals |
#7 Marian (Ind.) |
W, 52-27 |
| Semifinals |
#3 Indiana Wesleyan |
W, 38-7 |
| Championship |
#12 Keiser (Fla.) |
W, 35-25 |
| 2021 (Postseason Record: 2-1) |
| First Round |
#16 Central Methodist (Mo.) |
W, 24-7 |
| Quarterfinals |
#7 Marian (Ind.) |
W, 25-20 |
| Semifinals |
#2 Morningside |
L, 28-19 |
| 2020 (Postseason Record: 3-1) |
| First Round |
#10 Dickinson State (N.D.) |
W 31-7 |
| Quarterfinals |
#2 Grand View |
W 27-24 |
| Semifinals |
#1 Morningside |
W 44-41 |
| Championship |
#3 Lindsey Wilson (Ky.) |
L 45-13 |
| 2019 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| First Round |
Saint Xavier |
L 25-20 |
| 2018 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| First Round |
Dickinson State |
L 14-6 |
| 2017 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| First Round |
Langston |
W 55-7 |
| Quarterfinals |
Saint Francis (Ind.) |
L 30-3 |
| 2014 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| First Round |
Missouri Valley |
L 20-17 (2OT) |
| 2013 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| First Round |
Missouri Valley |
L 38-13 |
| 2012 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| First Round |
Marian (Ind.) |
L 42-32 |
| 2006 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| First Round |
Black Hills State (S.D.) |
W 17-10 |
| Quarterfinals |
Missouri Valley |
L 33-26 |
| 2003 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| First Round |
Ottawa (Kan.) |
W 36-33 |
| Quarterfinals |
Sioux Falls (S.D.) |
L 33-7 |
| 2000 (Postseason Record: 2-1) |
| First Round |
Benedictine (Kan.) |
W 27-26 |
| Quarterfinals |
St. Ambrose (Iowa) |
W 21-14 |
| Semifinals |
Northwestern Oklahoma |
L 42-7 |
| 1996 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| First Round |
Valley City State (N.D.) |
W 14-7 |
| Quarterfinals |
Sioux Falls (S.D.) |
L 52-21 |
| 1994 (Postseason Record: 2-1) |
| First Round |
Trinity (Ill.) |
W 38-20 |
| Quarterfinals |
Minot State (N.D.) |
W 28-26 |
| Semifinals |
Pacific Lutheran (Wash.) |
L 28-7 |
| 1992 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| First Round |
Baker (Kan.) |
L 21-20 |
| 1988 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| First Round |
Sioux Falls (S.D.) |
W 14-9 |
| Quarterfinals |
Wisconsin-LaCrosse |
L 45-33 |
| 1985 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| Quarterfinals |
Benedictine (Kan.) |
W 32-22 |
| Semifinals |
Wisconsin-LaCrosse |
L 35-28 (3OT) |
| 1984 (Postseason Record: 2-1) NATIONAL RUNNER-UP |
| Quarterfinals |
Southwestern (Kan.) |
W 45-23 |
| Semifinals |
Baker (Kan.) |
W 19-2 |
| Finals |
Linfield (Ore.) |
L 33-22 |
| 1983 (Postseason Record: 3-0) NATIONAL CHAMPIONS |
| Quarterfinals |
St. Thomas |
W 17-10 |
| Semifinals |
William Jewell (Mo.) |
W 30-12 |
| Finals |
Pacific Lutheran (Wash.) |
W 25-21 |
| 1982 (Postseason Record: 1-1) |
| Quarterfinals |
St. John's (Minn.) |
W 33-28 |
| Semifinals |
William Jewell (Mo.) |
L 23-10 |
| 1979 (Postseason Record: 2-1) NATIONAL RUNNER-UP |
| Quarterfinals |
Midland Lutheran (Neb.) |
W 40-27 |
| Semifinals |
Bethany (Kan.) |
W 49-21 |
| Finals |
Findlay (Ohio) |
L 51-6 |
| 1978 (Postseason Record: 0-1) |
| Quarterfinals |
Concordia (Minn.) |
L 49-0 |
| 1973 (Postseason Record: 2-0) NATIONAL CHAMPIONS |
| Semifinals |
William Jewell (Mo.) |
W 28-2 |
| Finals |
Glenville State |
W 10-3 |
| 1972 (Postseason Record: 1-1) NATIONAL RUNNER-UP |
| Semifinals |
Franklin College |
W 13-6 |
| Finals |
Missouri Southern |
L 14-21 |
| Overall Postseason Record: 33-22 |
| NATIONAL CHAMPIONS (3): 1973, 1983, 2022 |
| NATIONAL RUNNERS-UP (4): 1972, 1979, 1984, 2020, 2023 |
| NATIONAL SEMIFINALS (5): 1982, 1985, 1994, 2000, 2021 |
| NATIONAL QUARTERFINALS (6): 1978, 1988, 1996, 2003, 2006, 2017 |
